Our Australian-based online pet store—MyPetZone—was approached by Amazon last year, asking if we were interested in selling on their platform. To encourage us to take up their offer, Amazon offered us an account representative who would work with us to setup our account and grow our sales on their platform.

We were sent near-identical proposition emails by three different Amazon employees during the week we spend deciding whether we should give it a go. It was pretty clear that they were mass mailing every business in their targeted industry (in this case—pet supplies) with very little analysis or coordination.

Nevertheless, after a few emails back and forth, and a long phone conversation, we decided we’d give selling on Amazon a shot.

Deciding between Dropship and Fulfilled-by-Amazon

Amazon offer two different ways to sell on their website: Dropship, where you dispatch orders from your own warehouse using your own couriers; and Fullfilled-by-Amazon (FBA), where you send your stock to Amazon’s distribution center for storage and dispatch.

Amazon have substantially cheaper delivery from their distribution center (located in Melbourne), but they charge you a fee to store your products. As we sell many large products (like bags of dog food) with very low value-per-kilogram, the FBA storage costs were quite considerable.

An Amazon distribution center in Britain.

We didn’t know how our products would perform on Amazon, and the costs associated with freighting the stock to them (and potentially back to us) made it too financially risky to go with the FBA option. We settles on the dropship model as the safest way to give Amazon a shot.

Our account setup

After we had provided Amazon with the necessary information to create our product listings, we heard no communication from them for several weeks.

Suddenly, without any prior warning that our listings were live, we received our first order. Amazon decided that all of our listings should offer free shipping, and as we weren’t notified that the account was active, we hadn’t been given an opportunity to setup shipping zones/rates. The product ordered (a catnip spray) was priced at $6.58, and cost us $6.95 to mail to the customer.

We expressed our disappointment that free shipping had been added to all our listings to our Amazon representative. No response was received.

We rushed to get our shipping rates added so there would be no further money-losing orders. Once that issue was behind us, we started noticing that there were quite a few discrepancies between the inventory data we sent Amazon, and what their listing team had added to our account.

A manual review through all 1000-ish products revealed dozens of pricing/description errors, hundreds of missing products, and a handful of really bizarre issues. In addition to our pet products, we were also apparently selling cheese graters, digital cameras, desktop computers, and a $145 coffee mug.

We reached out to our account representative about the many inventory errors. No response was received.

Integration with WooCommerce

We used a product called WP-Lister Pro for Amazon to connect our WooCommerce-powered online store to Amazon. It’s currently priced at $149 USD per year.

Setting up the plugin took a few hours, but once we’d synced the plugin with our inventory for the first time, it was very much a “set and forget” solution.

Our product listings in WP-Lister Pro for Amazon

The plugin periodically sends inventory and price updates to Amazon, and any Amazon orders were automatically pulled across as normal WooCommerce orders. This allowed us to dispatch Amazon orders with no changes to our existing workflow and no need for additional staff training.

Performance of the account

After six months, Amazon was only accounting for between 1-2% of our monthly sales.

We found that most of the products that we were first to introduce to Amazon inevitably became part of their “sold by Amazon” inventory. With their superior buying power and more affordable shipping (due to economies of scale), they were able to offer products at prices we simply couldn’t—especially when we’re paying them 8% commission.

After we paid GST, shipping costs, cost of goods, Amazon fees, and Amazon commission; in an industry with notoriously thin margins, selling on Amazon was just not a viable option for our business.

Will we continue to sell with Amazon?

At the time of writing, we have requested the closure of our Seller account and the immediate transfer of any outstanding balance. The middling sales volume, frequent issues, and volume and the complete lack of support from Amazon made it an easy decision.

We’re much happier selling through our own WooCommerce-powered store. Our own store gives us far greater control over our inventory and how it’s displayed, more opportunity to build customer relationships, and (most importantly) doesn’t require us to pay a cut to a platform that doesn’t really do a lot to help its sellers.

Leave a Reply